NZ GENERAL 1271 RE MEDIA MAKE PENIS FAST SPAMMER OPERATING OUT OF NEW ZEALAND PICTURE OF SPAMMER
From: Nicolaas Hawkins (raptor@no-spam)
Subject: Re: [MEDIA]: make penis fast spammer operating out of New Zealand (Picture of spammer)
Date: Sat, 16 Aug 2003 10:28:27 +0000 (UTC)


On 17 Aug 2003 Uncle StoatWarbler wrote :

> > Picture of the spammer and a spectracularly clueless writeup at:
> > http://www.stuff.co.nz/stuff/0,2106,2628999a11,00.html > > Who's like to do the honours and add him to the gallery?
> > >
Why give the scammy, scummy cunt any [more] free publicity?

-- Nicolaas.

- Plerase don't throw your cigarette butts in the urinal - it makes them soggy and hard to light.






From: "Uncle StoatWarbler" (alanb+google4@no-spam)
Subject: Re: [MEDIA]: make penis fast spammer operating out of New Zealand (Picture of spammer)
Date: Sat, 16 Aug 2003 13:30:48 +0000

On Sat, 16 Aug 2003 10:28:27 +0000, Nicolaas Hawkins wrote:

>> >> Who's like to do the honours and add him to the gallery?
>>
> Why give the scammy, scummy cunt any [more] free publicity?

This is the kind of publicity he doesn't want. The kind which makes ISPs reluctant to host him.

Oh, and in response to DPF's comment about the DMA claims that there are no real spammers in NZ, they're using narrow definitions.

Steve Baron has been large-scale fax spamming in NZ for years and has attempted to branch out into mail spamming several times.

www.baron-marketing.co.nz, hosted at Quik (who supposedly nuked him a couple of years ago after his last round of mail spam)

He even admits it's receiver cost advertising (at approx 4c/page) at http://www.baron-marketing.co.nz/trends.htm
registrant_contact_name: Baron Marketing Ltd registrant_contact_address1: PO Box 38938
registrant_contact_address2: Howick registrant_contact_city: AUCKLAND registrant_contact_country: NZ (NEW ZEALAND)
registrant_contact_phone: +64 9 537 3025
registrant_contact_fax: +64 9 522 8844
registrant_contact_email: marketing@no-spam %
admin_contact_name: Marketing Dept admin_contact_address1: PO Box 38938
admin_contact_address2: Howick admin_contact_city: AUCKLAND admin_contact_country: NZ (NEW ZEALAND)
admin_contact_phone: +64 9 537 3025
admin_contact_fax: +64 9 522 8844
admin_contact_email: marketing@no-spam %
technical_contact_name: Webmaster at Quik Internet technical_contact_address1: P.O.Box 183 Kumeu technical_contact_address2: Auckland, New Zealand technical_contact_phone: +64 9 414 6001
technical_contact_fax: +64 9 414 6002
technical_contact_email: webmaster@no-spam %

Roll on a NZ TCPA.


From: Steve B (s.bell@no-spam)
Subject: Re: [MEDIA]: make penis fast spammer operating out of New Zealand (Picture of spammer)
Date: Sun, 17 Aug 2003 06:04:24 +1200

On Sat, 16 Aug 2003 12:26:25 +0000, "Uncle StoatWarbler"
<alanb+google4@no-spam> wrote:

>
>Picture of the spammer and a spectracularly clueless And/or biased
>writeup at:
>
>http://www.stuff.co.nz/stuff/0,2106,2628999a11,00.html >
This is, I agree, a spectacularly inept piece of "journalism", barely deserving of the name. Rule 1. "get both sides of the story" (and if possible comment from a knowledgeable neutral party) has been blatantly violated. (Ducks, expecting a large stone to come crashing through the panes of my greenhouse).

>Who's like to do the honours and add him to the gallery?
>
Who; the spammer or the reporter (actually a her)?

I was hoping it was going to be the same reporter as did the story on how internet child-porn collectors were (most?/all?/actually 15% if you're very generous with your definitions) working with children, and how these people (most?/all? actually 11%, including the undie thieves) had convictions for "real life" sexual offences, etc. But no,
it appears the Press has at least two inept and/or biased reporters on internet questions.

Anna Claridge (spam) and Yvonne Martin (porn)
Honourable mention, Diana Dekker, Dompost, for her piece on email interception, which significantly failed to mention the impact of the Crimes Amendment No. 6 Act, despite my having specifically drawn it to her attention.

Steve B.


Subject: Re: [MEDIA]: make penis fast spammer operating out of New Zealand (Picture of spammer)
From: wolfgang+gnus20030816T120615@no-spam (Wolfgang S. Rupprecht)
Date: Sat, 16 Aug 2003 19:06:49 GMT

"Uncle StoatWarbler" <alanb+google4@no-spam> writes:
> Picture of the spammer and a spectracularly clueless writeup at:
> > http://www.stuff.co.nz/stuff/0,2106,2628999a11,00.html > > Who's like to do the honours and add him to the gallery?

Do we have enough spammer pix yet to make a deck of spammer playing cards?

-wolfgang -- Wolfgang S. Rupprecht http://www.wsrcc.com/wolfgang/
(NOTE: The email address above is valid. Edit it at your own peril.)


From: LeftAintRight (kdavies@no-spam)
Subject: Re: [MEDIA]: make penis fast spammer operating out of New Zealand
Date: Sun, 17 Aug 2003 08:22:09 +1200

Uncle StoatWarbler wrote:
> Picture of the spammer and a spectracularly clueless writeup at:
> > http://www.stuff.co.nz/stuff/0,2106,2628999a11,00.html > > Who's like to do the honours and add him to the gallery?
> >
Looks like his spamming days may be numbered.

http://www.aardvark.co.nz/daily/2003/n081501.shtml

From: Barry Lennox (pbarryplennoxp@no-spam)
Subject: Re: [MEDIA]: make penis fast spammer operating out of New Zealand (Picture of spammer)
Date: Sun, 17 Aug 2003 09:27:56 +1200

On Sat, 16 Aug 2003 12:26:25 +0000, "Uncle StoatWarbler"
<alanb+google4@no-spam> wrote:

>
>Picture of the spammer and a spectracularly clueless writeup at:
>
>http://www.stuff.co.nz/stuff/0,2106,2628999a11,00.html >
>Who's like to do the honours and add him to the gallery?
>

I see he has had death threats, Maybe we get lucky and one of them works out.


From: Bruce Simpson (checksigformyre@no-spam)
Subject: Re: [MEDIA]: make penis fast spammer operating out of New Zealand (Picture of spammer)
Date: Sun, 17 Aug 2003 10:26:46 +1200

On Sun, 17 Aug 2003 00:02:41 +0000, "Uncle StoatWarbler"
<alanb+google4@no-spam> wrote:

>On Sun, 17 Aug 2003 08:22:09 +1200, LeftAintRight wrote:
>
>>> >> Looks like his spamming days may be numbered.
>> >> http://www.aardvark.co.nz/daily/2003/n081501.shtml >
>A pretty self-serving press release, all told.
>
>The original reporter had already tipped off all these agencies, nice to >see Internet NZ waltzing in to seek the glory. It's about what you'd >expect from that mob....

Actually, it wouldn't surprise me if those agencies were powerless to act without a formal complaint from the public. Bureaucrats are seldom keen to do anything when they don't absolutely have to.

--
you can contact me via http://aardvark.co.nz/contact/


From: "Uncle StoatWarbler" (alanb+google4@no-spam)
Subject: Re: [MEDIA]: make penis fast spammer operating out of New Zealand (Picture of spammer)
Date: Sat, 16 Aug 2003 23:16:54 +0000

On Sun, 17 Aug 2003 06:04:24 +1200, Steve B wrote:

>>Picture of the spammer and a spectracularly clueless > And/or biased
It's pretty much a rip of Juha's story for the NZ Hairoiled.

>>Who's like to do the honours and add him to the gallery?
>>
> Who; the spammer or the reporter (actually a her)?

The spammer. For the nz.* crowd: www.chickenboner.com

From: "Howard Johnson" (hojos@no-spam)
Subject: Re: [MEDIA]: make penis fast spammer operating out of New Zealand (Picture of spammer)
Date: Sun, 17 Aug 2003 11:23:11 +1200

"Uncle StoatWarbler" <alanb+google4@no-spam> wrote in message news:pan.2003.08.17.00.02.41.717559@no-spam > On Sun, 17 Aug 2003 08:22:09 +1200, LeftAintRight wrote:
>
> >>
> > Looks like his spamming days may be numbered.
> >
> > http://www.aardvark.co.nz/daily/2003/n081501.shtml >
> A pretty self-serving press release, all told.
>
> The original reporter had already tipped off all these agencies, nice to > see Internet NZ waltzing in to seek the glory. It's about what you'd > expect from that mob....
>
>
>
BURN THE WITCH !!!
Lets all go marching through Burnside with scythes and torches and do it the Christchurch way.
;-)


From: "Uncle StoatWarbler" (alanb+google4@no-spam)
Subject: Re: [MEDIA]: make penis fast spammer operating out of New Zealand (Picture of spammer)
Date: Sun, 17 Aug 2003 00:02:41 +0000

On Sun, 17 Aug 2003 08:22:09 +1200, LeftAintRight wrote:

>> > Looks like his spamming days may be numbered.
> > http://www.aardvark.co.nz/daily/2003/n081501.shtml
A pretty self-serving press release, all told.

The original reporter had already tipped off all these agencies, nice to see Internet NZ waltzing in to seek the glory. It's about what you'd expect from that mob....


Subject: Re: [MEDIA]: make penis fast spammer operating out of New Zealand (Picture of spammer)
From: Lesley Walker (delirium+usenet@no-spam)
Date: 17 Aug 2003 15:30:20 +1200

"Uncle StoatWarbler" <alanb+google4@no-spam> wrote:
> www.chickenboner.com
Is there meant to be something relevant on that page? If so I can't see it (using Mozilla or IE5). I see a picture (Uncle Sam variant), one of those mostly-pointless ribbons, and a little animated banner explaining what spam is. I see no links except the ribbon one.

Lesley Walker Wellington, New Zealand -- I can avoid being quoted by saying nothing,
and it seems to work fairly well.
Chuck Falconer news.software.readers news:3C10CAF6.DC42630@no-spam

From: DPF (david@no-spam)
Subject: Re: [MEDIA]: make penis fast spammer operating out of New Zealand (Picture of spammer)
Date: Sun, 17 Aug 2003 16:26:52 +1200

On Sun, 17 Aug 2003 00:02:41 +0000, "Uncle StoatWarbler"
<alanb+google4@no-spam> wrote:

>On Sun, 17 Aug 2003 08:22:09 +1200, LeftAintRight wrote:
>
>>> >> Looks like his spamming days may be numbered.
>> >> http://www.aardvark.co.nz/daily/2003/n081501.shtml >
>A pretty self-serving press release, all told.
>
>The original reporter had already tipped off all these agencies, nice to >see Internet NZ waltzing in to seek the glory. It's about what you'd >expect from that mob....

Oh shit, so giving up around six hours of my weekend to put all the documents together in one place, do screen dumps, check with lawyers,
write up actual complaints relating to specific acts is all for nothing? I've even waded my way through enough penis growth websites to last a life-time.

DPF --
Blog: http://www.kiwiblog.co.nz E-mail: david@no-spam ICQ: 29964527
MSN: dpf666@no-spam

From: Peter Metcalfe (metcalph@no-spam)
Subject: Re: [MEDIA]: make penis fast spammer operating out of New Zealand (Picture of spammer)
Date: Sun, 17 Aug 2003 16:49:55 +1200

In article <as0ujvs1avpr9fne5dngosjb5ge69t0edg@no-spam>, david@no-spam says...

> I've even waded my way through enough penis growth websites > to last a life-time.

How many did you wade through before becoming convinced that it was a load of crap?

--Peter Metcalfe

From: morrisseybreen@no-spam (Morrissey Breen)
Subject: Re: [MEDIA]: make penis fast spammer operating out of New Zealand (Picture of spammer)
Date: 17 Aug 2003 02:44:51 -0700

Barry Lennox <pbarryplennoxp@no-spam> wrote in message news:<na8tjv4dammah8jlffgq2lfugofnlaoolc@no-spam>...


Why all the fuss? This is what he's selling....
http://www.lazland.com/karikatur/pictures/penis-developer.jpg

From: IRO (iro.dot.spring.a@no-spam)
Subject: Re: [MEDIA]: make penis fast spammer operating out of New Zealand (Picture of spammer)
Date: Sun, 17 Aug 2003 22:16:46 +1200

In article <L1z%a.11888$9f7.1368923@no-spam>,
"Howard Johnson" <hojos@no-spam> wrote:

> > The original reporter had already tipped off all these agencies, nice to > > see Internet NZ waltzing in to seek the glory. It's about what you'd > > expect from that mob....
> >
> >
> >
> BURN THE WITCH !!!
> Lets all go marching through Burnside with scythes and torches and do it the > Christchurch way.

It would be a bit of a long haul from Burnside, he supposedly lives over at Northwood.

-- ...IRO
Reply to <iro.spring<at>paradise<dot>net<dot>nz>


From: support@no-spam (ShaneA)
Subject: Re: [MEDIA]: make penis fast spammer operating out of New Zealand (Picture of spammer)
Date: 17 Aug 2003 03:25:11 -0700

Hi Everybody. Shane here. I would like to say that ive closed my spam opperation, deleted everything and sacked all the affiliates. This is perminant we will not reopen. Im truely sorry for anyone who got emailed or offended, but i can assure it was the last.

I hope oneday the hatrid i have created with you guys and girls can eventually be forgiven. I never ment any harm in what I was doing If anyone wants to contact me,
email is best - support@no-spam

From: Mark Harris (news@no-spam)
Subject: Re: [MEDIA]: make penis fast spammer operating out of New Zealand (Picture of spammer)
Date: Sun, 17 Aug 2003 22:34:11 +1200

On Sun, 17 Aug 2003 06:04:24 +1200, Steve B <s.bell@no-spam> wrote:

>This is, I agree, a spectacularly inept piece of "journalism", barely >deserving of the name. Rule 1. "get both sides of the story" (and if >possible comment from a knowledgeable neutral party) has been >blatantly violated. (Ducks, expecting a large stone to come crashing >through the panes of my greenhouse).
>
Sadly, Steve, much of what passes for jounalism in this and many other countries is nothing more than rewrites (and sometimes, not even that)
of the press releases from the corporate flacks and shills.

There are few bylines in this country that I trouble with any more. I read yours because I want to find out what hare you're chasing after now, and because occasionally, you get your mitts into something worth reading. ;-)

Russell Brown and Adam Gifford are two whose tenaciousness and research capability I respect. Very few others.

A plague on all your houses, sirrah!

<grumps>

mark -- "Someone's been mean to you! Tell me who it is, so I can punch him tastefully."
- Ralph Bakshi's Mighty Mouse

From: "Howard Johnson" (hojos@no-spam)
Subject: Re: [MEDIA]: make penis fast spammer operating out of New Zealand (Picture of spammer)
Date: Sun, 17 Aug 2003 22:59:23 +1200

"IRO" <iro.dot.spring.a@no-spam> wrote in message news:iro.dot.spring.a-BD5CF4.22164617082003@no-spam > In article <L1z%a.11888$9f7.1368923@no-spam>,
> "Howard Johnson" <hojos@no-spam> wrote:
>
> > > The original reporter had already tipped off all these agencies, nice to > > > see Internet NZ waltzing in to seek the glory. It's about what you'd > > > expect from that mob....
> > >
> > >
> > >
> > BURN THE WITCH !!!
> > Lets all go marching through Burnside with scythes and torches and do it the > > Christchurch way.
>
> It would be a bit of a long haul from Burnside, he supposedly lives over > at Northwood.
>
Perhaps we could send the Spamish Inquisition.
;-)


From: fredfighter@no-spam (Fred the Red Shirt)
Subject: Re: [MEDIA]: make penis fast spammer operating out of New Zealand (Picture of spammer)
Date: 17 Aug 2003 09:05:10 -0700

Lesley Walker <delirium+usenet@no-spam> wrote in message news:<Xns93DA9DB8CB9CCdelirious@no-spam>...

> "Uncle StoatWarbler" <alanb+google4@no-spam> wrote:
> > www.chickenboner.com > > Is there meant to be something relevant on that page? If so I can't > see it (using Mozilla or IE5). I see a picture (Uncle Sam variant), > one of those mostly-pointless ribbons, and a little animated banner > explaining what spam is. I see no links except the ribbon one.
>
What animation? All I see on the banner is HAL staring out at me.

I think it is not intended that the unwashed masses should be able to casually navigate the site. WHen Shiksaa wants to show us something she posts the full URL.

--
FF

From: "Uncle StoatWarbler" (alanb+google4@no-spam)
Subject: Re: [MEDIA]: make penis fast spammer operating out of New Zealand (Picture of spammer)
Date: Sun, 17 Aug 2003 19:21:46 +0000

On Sun, 17 Aug 2003 03:25:11 -0700, ShaneA wrote:

> NNTP-Posting-Host: 210.55.220.52

52.220.55.210.in-addr.arpa domain name pointer 210-55-220-52.adsl.ihug.co.nz.

I hope someone's letting Ihug know...

> Hi Everybody. Shane here. I would like to say that ive closed my spam > opperation, deleted everything and sacked all the affiliates. This is > perminant we will not reopen. Im truely sorry for anyone who got emailed > or offended, but i can assure it was the last.

In the words of that beer advert:

"Yeah, right"

> I hope oneday the hatrid i have created with you guys and girls can > eventually be forgiven. I never ment any harm in what I was doing If > anyone wants to contact me,

I hope that you get convicted of fraud and bogus medical claims, plus the tax evasion you seem to have tacitly admitted to at least one reporter.


From: "Uncle StoatWarbler" (alanb+google4@no-spam)
Subject: Re: [MEDIA]: make penis fast spammer operating out of New Zealand (Picture of spammer)
Date: Sun, 17 Aug 2003 20:34:53 +0000

On Sun, 17 Aug 2003 16:26:52 +1200, DPF wrote:

> Oh shit, so giving up around six hours of my weekend to put all the > documents together in one place, do screen dumps, check with lawyers,
> write up actual complaints relating to specific acts is all for nothing?
> I've even waded my way through enough penis growth websites to last a > life-time.

Oh golly gosh, a WHOLE 6 hours.
I guess an hour of that was writing the press release.

I spent more time than that assisting Juha to get the information he needed to find the spammer in the first place.

Juha spent 3 weeks tracking the guy down and getting the interviews, then another week checking with the various agencies at my suggestion, holding off publication until he got responses back and things stirred up somewhat.

To have ISOCNZ/InternetNZ show up with self-promotional press releases AFTER all the legwork has been done by other people _IS_ glory seeking.

The spammer story and exposure is the result of a lot of hard work by Juha Saarinen and I'm offended you're trying to cash in on it politically,
as are a number of other people.

A lot of people have invested years of hard work into trying to deal with the spam problem. It's typical that the glory seekers show up at the last moments to try and claim the results as theirs.

Unfortunately for you and Internet NZ, the people concerned ARE admins and they have _long_ memories...

Subject: Re: [MEDIA]: make penis fast spammer operating out of New Zealand (Picture of spammer)
From: Lesley Walker (delirium+usenet@no-spam)
Date: 18 Aug 2003 13:21:41 +1200

fredfighter@no-spam (Fred the Red Shirt) wrote:
> I think it is not intended that the unwashed masses should be > able to casually navigate the site. WHen Shiksaa wants to show > us something she posts the full URL.

<groan>

So I have wasted my time trying to follow "Uncle StoatWarbler's" cryptic comments. Thanks for at least putting me out of my misery, Fred.

Lesley Walker Wellington, New Zealand -- I can avoid being quoted by saying nothing,
and it seems to work fairly well.
Chuck Falconer news.software.readers news:3C10CAF6.DC42630@no-spam

From: s.bell@no-spam (Steve Bell)
Subject: Re: [MEDIA]: make penis fast spammer operating out of New Zealand (Picture of spammer)
Date: 17 Aug 2003 19:56:44 -0700

fredfighter@no-spam (Fred the Red Shirt) wrote:

> He buys lists, fools other idiots into doing a lto fo hsi spamming...

I thought for a minute that was an unfamilar technical term from the world of spammers; maybe one of the spams I get in Chinese characters.

But I see what you mean.

I'd still be interested to know what was actually being flogged by the Japanese spam I got once; it was called a "FunnyGo", and was pictured (alongside a lot of dildos and similar equipment) with no clue as to scale. A flat horizontal rectangular platform with some tubular device held horizontally above it on an arm.

Might have been anything from an overhead projector to a tanning bed.
But I can't imagine how something that shape would fit into the "marital aids" class that it appeared to be in.

I can't help it; 99.9% of spam anmnoys the hell out of me, but some just arouses my curiosity. But before I get blamed for perpetuating it, I can truthfully say I've never bought anything from a spammer -
or a telemarketer.

I may have purchased the odd thing from a junk-mailed catalog, tho'

Steve B.

Why would you want to make your penis fast? :-) I've seen creams and sprays designed to do just the opposite.
Maybe if it's about to drop off or its colour is fading...


Subject: Re: [MEDIA]: make penis fast spammer operating out of New Zealand (Picture of spammer)
From: Lesley Walker (delirium+usenet@no-spam)
Date: 18 Aug 2003 17:04:48 +1200

fredfighter@no-spam (Fred the Red Shirt) wrote:
> What animation? All I see on the banner is HAL staring out at > me.
Forgot to respond to this bit. It's a short conversation between Dave and HAL which starts off with "What exactly is spam, HAL?" and covers the basics. An animated gif by the look of it, but it just has words. HAL's "eye" changes slightly when Dave speaks.

Lesley Walker Wellington, New Zealand -- I can avoid being quoted by saying nothing,
and it seems to work fairly well.
Chuck Falconer news.software.readers news:3C10CAF6.DC42630@no-spam

From: DPF (david@no-spam)
Subject: Re: [MEDIA]: make penis fast spammer operating out of New Zealand (Picture of spammer)
Date: Mon, 18 Aug 2003 18:05:56 +1200

On Sun, 17 Aug 2003 20:34:53 +0000, "Uncle StoatWarbler"
<alanb+google4@no-spam> wrote:

>On Sun, 17 Aug 2003 16:26:52 +1200, DPF wrote:
>
>> Oh shit, so giving up around six hours of my weekend to put all the >> documents together in one place, do screen dumps, check with lawyers,
>> write up actual complaints relating to specific acts is all for nothing?
>> I've even waded my way through enough penis growth websites to last a >> life-time.
>
>Oh golly gosh, a WHOLE 6 hours. >
>I guess an hour of that was writing the press release.

Actually that was Friday while waiting for a plane at Auckland Airport (returning from having just taken a half day off work to attend an anti spam meeting in Auckland)

>I spent more time than that assisting Juha to get the information he >needed to find the spammer in the first place.

Alan - this isn't some pissing contest where we are competing. Many people fight spam, and I have always appreciated those who do.
>Juha spent 3 weeks tracking the guy down and getting the interviews, then >another week checking with the various agencies at my suggestion, holding >off publication until he got responses back and things stirred up >somewhat.
>
>To have ISOCNZ/InternetNZ show up with self-promotional press releases >AFTER all the legwork has been done by other people _IS_ glory seeking.
>
>The spammer story and exposure is the result of a lot of hard work by >Juha Saarinen and I'm offended you're trying to cash in on it politically,
>as are a number of other people.

You seem to think this is about credit - I'm more concerned with stopping spam - as is Juha I would say.

I absolutely agree - Juha did a great job tracking the guy down and getting a major story in the Herald about it. He has all our thanks.
We need more journalists like him.

But the reality is that different people can contribute to stopping spam in different ways. Journalists can get stories published but generally they can't lodge complaints with regulatory authorities.
Advocacy groups like INZ can lodge complaints, and can help get greater publicity on an issue. Also INZ is well poised to lobby NZ Govt to pass anti spam legislation (if that is what the members want us to do).
If you want to keep running your own private battles Alan, you're free to do so. I respect the huge contribution you have made to battling spam. But regardless of your opinion, I'm going to keep doing what I can to stop spam.

DPF --
Blog: http://www.kiwiblog.co.nz E-mail: david@no-spam ICQ: 29964527
MSN: dpf666@no-spam

From: Joe (JoeBloggs@no-spam)
Subject: Re: [MEDIA]: make penis fast spammer operating out of New Zealand (Picture of spammer)
Date: Mon, 18 Aug 2003 23:32:49 +1200

On Mon, 18 Aug 2003 18:05:56 +1200, DPF <david@no-spam> wrote:

>On Sun, 17 Aug 2003 20:34:53 +0000, "Uncle StoatWarbler"
><alanb+google4@no-spam> wrote:
>
>>On Sun, 17 Aug 2003 16:26:52 +1200, DPF wrote:
>>
>>> Oh shit, so giving up around six hours of my weekend to put all the >>> documents together in one place, do screen dumps, check with lawyers,
>>> write up actual complaints relating to specific acts is all for nothing?
>>> I've even waded my way through enough penis growth websites to last a >>> life-time.
>>
>>Oh golly gosh, a WHOLE 6 hours. >>
>>I guess an hour of that was writing the press release.
>
>Actually that was Friday while waiting for a plane at Auckland Airport >(returning from having just taken a half day off work to attend an >anti spam meeting in Auckland)
>
>>I spent more time than that assisting Juha to get the information he >>needed to find the spammer in the first place.
>
>Alan - this isn't some pissing contest where we are competing. Many >people fight spam, and I have always appreciated those who do. >
>>Juha spent 3 weeks tracking the guy down and getting the interviews, then >>another week checking with the various agencies at my suggestion, holding >>off publication until he got responses back and things stirred up >>somewhat.
>>
>>To have ISOCNZ/InternetNZ show up with self-promotional press releases >>AFTER all the legwork has been done by other people _IS_ glory seeking.
>>
>>The spammer story and exposure is the result of a lot of hard work by >>Juha Saarinen and I'm offended you're trying to cash in on it politically,
>>as are a number of other people.
>
>You seem to think this is about credit - I'm more concerned with >stopping spam - as is Juha I would say.
>
>I absolutely agree - Juha did a great job tracking the guy down and >getting a major story in the Herald about it. He has all our thanks.
>We need more journalists like him.
>
>But the reality is that different people can contribute to stopping >spam in different ways. Journalists can get stories published but >generally they can't lodge complaints with regulatory authorities.
>Advocacy groups like INZ can lodge complaints, and can help get >greater publicity on an issue. Also INZ is well poised to lobby NZ >Govt to pass anti spam legislation (if that is what the members want >us to do). >
>If you want to keep running your own private battles Alan, you're free >to do so. I respect the huge contribution you have made to battling >spam. But regardless of your opinion, I'm going to keep doing what I >can to stop spam.
>
>DPF
Thanks to the efforts and team of the anti spammers.
Cheers *


From: "Uncle StoatWarbler" (alanb+google4@no-spam)
Subject: Re: [MEDIA]: make penis fast spammer operating out of New Zealand (Picture of spammer)
Date: Mon, 18 Aug 2003 14:41:58 +0000

On Mon, 18 Aug 2003 18:05:56 +1200, DPF wrote:

> You seem to think this is about credit - I'm more concerned with > stopping spam - as is Juha I would say.

You could have filed the complaints without making a press release about it. The fact that you did seems to indicate you're more interested in the publicity than the spammer being shut down.

Now that the spammer's said he's sorry, I gather you're going to withdraw the complaints. Why?

Do we forgive bank robbers and let them continue once they promise to continue? At a claimed 100 million messages/day and recipient ISP handling costs of around 0.1c/Message, that's $100k/day (US$).

Add in the time taken to Just Hit Delete (JHD) by humans and lost messages caused by being swamped in spam, so JHDing genuine mail, that's more like $1million/day.

How much did he make out of the spam? Why should be be allowed to retain any of it? Allowing that will only encourage more to try.

> But the reality is that different people can contribute to stopping spam > in different ways. Journalists can get stories published but generally > they can't lodge complaints with regulatory authorities. Advocacy groups > like INZ can lodge complaints, and can help get greater publicity on an > issue. Also INZ is well poised to lobby NZ Govt to pass anti spam > legislation (if that is what the members want us to do).

So far all I see out of INZ/ISOCNZ is a bunch of handwringing and attempts to redefine what spam is to please the DMA. you haven't even managed to get an ISP code of practice widely accepted after 5 years of trying.


From: werner@no-spam ()
Subject: Re: [MEDIA]: make penis fast spammer operating out of New Zealand (Picture of spammer)
Date: Mon, 18 Aug 2003 16:30:26 +0000 (UTC)

quoting "Uncle StoatWarbler" <alanb+google4@no-spam> :
>> You think this is about credit? I'm concerned with stopping spam...
> You could have filed the complaints without making a press release. Seems > you're more interested in the publicity than the spammer being shut down.

seems like a (foolish) cheap shot; even if you were right, there could be good (acceptable) reasons for such publicity (even if it was done with a personal business interest in mind)

> Now that the spammer's said he's sorry, I gather you're going to withdraw > the complaints. Why? Do we forgive bank robbers...

that's a valid question though... but I can think of answers that I might accept... (and I haven't followed this thread from the start, so I don't have an opinion on the details... yet :)

<< But the reality is that different people can contribute to stopping spam << in different ways. Journalists can get stories published but generally << they can't lodge complaints with regulatory authorities. Advocacy groups << like INZ can lodge complaints, and can help get greater publicity on an << issue. Also INZ is well poised to lobby NZ Govt on antispam issues...

...like this one. Sounds about right (and reasonable)

> So far all I see out of INZ/ISOCNZ is a bunch of handwringing and attempts > to redefine what spam is to please the DMA. you haven't even managed to > get an ISP code of practice widely accepted after 5 years of trying.

hmm, that sounds bad. 5 years, eh? How long did it take us to get the first sensible reaction out of UUnet though... ?
And how far have we gotten with them ?!?

-- Idi Amin, evil dictator of Uganda, died /"\ ASCII... ._.
in Saudi exile.... Good Riddance!!! \ / on Usenet /v\
Opt-out is *UNACCEPTABLE*, X EVERYTHING ELSE /( )\
(be that DoNotCallMe, DoNotSpamMe, DoNotRobMe) / \ IS BLOAT !! ^^ ^^